A most pleasingly atmospheric rendition of the tale, noirishly photographed and moodily set, this is the version which probably would have delighted Conan Doyle the most. There is one important plot change which enables the beautiful Alice Brandt to enjoy both a larger role and a more intriguing part in the proceedings. This change also builds up the parts of Dr Mortimer and Lord Charles, yet at the same time provides a nice introduction to the is-he-sinister or is-he-a-good-guy Barrymore, deftly played here by Fritz Rasp.
Despite the sting of its well-developed story, the spellbindingly atmospheric direction and the engrossing performances delivered by the entire cast, many fans may find this version somewhat disappointing. For at least three reasons: As in the novel, the part played in the narrative by Sherlock Holmes, though vital, is minimal. And in this version, not only has no attempt been made to enlarge his role, if anything both writer and director do their best to minimize it. Holmes does not even make his entrance for half-an-hour, and when he does finally appear, he has his back to the camera. It is Fritz Odemar, as Dr Watson, who receives the more favorable camera angles. And there is a purpose in this. It is Watson, not Holmes, who figures as the main protagonist of The Hound of the Baskervilles. For the bulk of the narrative, Holmes disappears. It is Watson and Lord Henry (Peter Voss) who take up the running. The movie is almost over, before Holmes closes in on the villain. And even so, this is not the obsessed, self-important Holmes we are accustomed to see taking charge. Another problem is that the title hound itself does not figure a great deal in the action, a downgrading which will undoubtedly rate as another major disappointment for fans. And finally, it could be argued that the script gives too much attention to Conan Doyle's red herring, the escaped convict, and not enough to the real villain.
This said, it must surely be admitted by all, that Odemar's interpretation of Watson—intelligent, charming, level-headed, courageous and resourceful—is much closer to Conan Doyle's conception than either the bungling, inveterately stupid Nigel Bruce or the self-effacing Ian Fleming.
One other player deserves special mention: Erich Ponto (Dr Winkel in The Third Man) who seems exactly right for Stapleton. A difficult part, superbly played.
- JohnHowardReid, imdb
小悬疑不惊悚，清新日系《消失的爱人》，喜欢黑木华多变的戏路。
年纪大了，看中二少年在犯蠢并送掉亲人中认识自我只觉得猪逼和无聊，除了卖情怀也不剩啥了
非常极度不喜欢女二的キャラ什么明るいbitch，男主，キモ。
双语字幕看起来，居然很多能看懂，学习有进步
漫画形式挺有意思，但本质就是我的恐怖妻子2.0吧。柄本佑演的有点油腻。。。
不温不火，典型的日片节奏。没大起大落，反而觉得像个小品。
太精彩了！！真真假假，或许最后的结尾也是fiction呢？这个留白真的拿捏住了！！
2022.04.23 三星半。看到介绍感觉有点好笑找来看 真真假假 漫画和现实虚实结合 薛定谔的不伦 有点意思。一直都没法get黑木华的颜 奈绪演的满眼只有工作的编辑真的太有趣了 完全没把男人当回事。最后往向副驾的那一眼 嗯～
蜘蛛侠对于一些人只是荷兰弟，可对于更多人，他是我们童年认识的第一个超英。这次的三虫同框是我十多年来的情怀，童年少年再到现在的青年。所以才对新一代的表现……
柄本佑演技好好，这个丈夫蠢萌的样子跟小明差不多~~虚虚实实交互映照的述事也很有意思~
《登堂入室》之“漫漫没想到”，好奇心和好胜心被拿捏得死死的。
虚虚实实，真真假假，切换的特别有趣，用漫画的方式引人进去，加剧了紧张感
黑木华好适合这种安静复仇的角色啊。。。第一次在电影里看到完全是工具人角色的男主，妻子和小三从来没把男人当成过一回事，妙啊
出轨不伦总要发生在盛夏。漫画与现实的交错、对话与场景的反复演绎，理智告别渣男老公同时也是欣喜迎接漫画老师，日本影视关于不伦的八百万种写法。
柄本佑看传真来的漫画时的样子，像极了我追漫画的样子！太好玩了这个电影哈哈哈哈，结尾我好喜欢哈哈哈哈哈哈 ed也好听！！
最好的复仇就是我从一开始就没原谅过你，为结局再加一星
从头到尾没人把丈夫当回事哈哈哈哈，结尾反转不错。最后 请问上哪找帅哥驾校教练
结尾真的很爽，不是那种狗血的爽，而是这种不骄不躁、不吵不闹，给了点希望后又致命一击的爽。
骗人，驾校没有这种教练，以及我对黑木华真的爱不起来。
柄本佑即便是个出轨的人设嫉妒吃起醋起来也还是可爱得要命啊，认真画画的样子可太迷人了；反转又反转，黑木华把一个有点神经质又腹黑的漫画家演活了。
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
